Sign in

    CarGurus Inc (CARG)

    Q4 2023 Earnings Summary

    Reported on Feb 25, 2025 (After Market Close)
    Pre-Earnings Price$23.89Last close (Feb 26, 2024)
    Post-Earnings Price$22.50Open (Feb 27, 2024)
    Price Change
    $-1.39(-5.82%)

    What went well

    • CarGurus' Marketplace business is demonstrating exceptional growth, achieving its highest-ever year-over-year QARSD growth, driven by multiple factors including pricing new dealers at market rates, upselling dealers to higher premium packages, and high adoption of additional products, leading to increased revenue and profitability.
    • The company expects its CarOffer segment to return to profitable growth in the next few quarters, due to operational improvements such as enhanced inspection, title transfer, and transportation capabilities, and reduced fixed costs, indicating potential margin expansion and increased shareholder value.
    • International operations are performing strongly, with revenue growth accelerating in Canada and achieving profitability in the U.K., contributing positively to the company's overall profitability without requiring significant additional marketing investments.

    What went wrong

    • The CarOffer business is currently unprofitable and may take several quarters to return to profitable growth, indicating operational challenges that could impact CarGurus' financial performance. ,
    • The acquisition of CarOffer resulted in significant expenses, including approximately $50 million in share-based compensation and a $75 million cash consideration, leading to a GAAP operating loss of $22 million, a GAAP net loss of $23 million, and a decrease in cash balance by $135 million, which may affect the company's financial health.
    • The company's first quarter guidance suggests a substantial increase in operating expenses—estimated between $15 million to $20 million—primarily driven by marketing spend and other factors, potentially impacting near-term profitability.

    Q&A Summary

    1. CarOffer Profitability Timeline
      Q: When will CarOffer return to profitable growth?
      A: Management expects CarOffer to return to profitable growth in the next few quarters, driven by operational efficiencies, product enhancements, and leadership rebuilding.

    2. First Quarter OpEx Increase
      Q: What's causing OpEx to rise in Q1?
      A: The rise in Q1 OpEx is due to seasonality of media spend, a new branding campaign, investments in Digital Wholesale, and nonrecurring Q4 benefits not repeating. Marketing spend is expected to remain constant through the year, but OpEx will decline as a percentage of revenue as the marketplace grows.

    3. Sales and Marketing Spend Outlook
      Q: Can you explain the outlook for sales and marketing spend?
      A: Marketing spend is within their control; they'll increase media spend in Q1 due to seasonality and maintain it throughout the year. They don't expect any major advertising push behind IMCO this year, and OpEx should decline as a percentage of revenue as they expand their franchise.

    4. Impact of Interest Rates
      Q: How do interest rates affect consumer demand and dealers?
      A: Rising interest rates have mixed effects. There's low correlation between interest rates and signing new dealers. Rising inventory and turn times encourage dealers to market more. A decrease in interest rates could lead to higher growth in their consumer finance revenue stream.

    5. International Profitability and Investment
      Q: How will international profitability evolve this year?
      A: Both Canada and the U.K. are profitable. While they're reinvesting in marketing to build on strong momentum, they're cautious to avoid overinvestment, ensuring margins remain healthy without needing increased marketing spend.

    6. Pricing Strategy and ABRs
      Q: What's the scope of pricing changes through ABRs?
      A: They will continue adjusting pricing for underpriced customers via Annual Business Reviews (ABRs), affecting about 20% of customers last year. They use multiple levers, including pricing at market rates, upselling, and product attachments. They expect a similar trajectory this year.

    7. CarGurus Ad Revenue Outlook
      Q: What's the outlook for ad revenue in 2024?
      A: Management is cautiously optimistic, expecting strong performance as OEMs increase spending and incentives are out. Upfront advertising interest is strong, suggesting ad revenue will return to solid performance.

    8. Sell My Car Product Expansion
      Q: When will Sell My Car expand nationwide?
      A: Expansion will be deliberate, focusing first on ensuring a high-quality consumer and dealer experience. They are optimizing pricing and evaluating economics before rolling out nationally to maximize benefits for both dealers and CarGurus.

    9. CarOffer Competitive Differentiation
      Q: How does CarOffer differ from competitors?
      A: CarOffer offers a digital instant trade platform, unlike traditional auctions. It acts as a "stock exchange" for vehicles, enabling dealers to buy and sell without attending timed auctions, creating a unique, capital-light solution in the market.

    10. GAAP Accounting for CarOffer
      Q: Is the CarOffer true-up complete in GAAP numbers?
      A: Yes, the transaction is closed, and they recorded approximately $50 million in share-based compensation in Q4 related to it. They don't expect any further true-ups going forward.

    Related Publications